20 Mar
Posted by omg_brb_icecreamtruck as Becca Smith, Carrie Smith, Elena Casagrande, Ghost Whisperer, IDW Publishing
Storyline: No Title
Date: March 19, 2008
Price: $3.99 US
Writer: Becca Smith and Carrie Smith
Artist: Elena Casagrande
Synopsis: Helping earthbound spirits cross into the Light is all in a day’s work for ghost whisperer Melinda Gordon. But Melinda gets more than she bargained for when she comes face-to-face with Osiris, Egyptian God of the Dead, who wants the souls for himself! But is Osiris all that he seems to be?
Opinion: If you like Ghost Whisperer the TV series you’ll like this new comic written by Becca Smith and Carrie Smith. Even if you’ve just seen a few shows you’ll know how the story flows from the first ghost sighting to the mystery of the ghost’s problems and the resolution of these concerns. The comic follows this same flow. It’s an easy story to read and follow and it keeps your interest.
Read the rest of my review after the jump.
My biggest complaint is that there is not much mystery due to the fact that the comic is limited in space, and the TV show has a whole hour to drag out the mystery. However, I must give Kudos to Becca and Carrie Smith for developing an ongoing villain/protagonist in this first comic. The small story that is resolved in the first comic is only the beginning of a much bigger problem that the Ghost Whisperer will have to face in later issues. This will undoubtedly bring the preliminary readers back for the second issue. I know I’ll be in line!
On another note those who watch Ghost Whisperer purely for Jennifer Love Hewitt’s sex appeal will not find this comic lacking in artistic detail. Though the heroine does not look much like the actress there are plenty of buxom beauties portrayed to appease that type of appetite.
Finally, the size of the comic is impressive! It’s easy for comics-based-on-shows to be laden with adverts and not much content but this book was thick and a pleasure to read! Well worth the money.
Rate This Issue:
3 Responses
Rayne
March 20th, 2008 at 8:24 am
1I do like the show, but I am always wary about trying out the comic book version. Your review makes it sound like this is one of the few times they got it right. I’m going to check it out.
omg_brb_icecreamtruck
March 20th, 2008 at 2:35 pm
2It can be hard for comics to follow a popular show, but this one gets it right. The comic sticks to the TV shows flow, so if that’s what you like about Ghost Whisperer give the comic a try!
JC
March 25th, 2008 at 8:21 pm
3I remember reading the Battlestar Galactica comics and not being very impressed - though I would like to point out that the show is very gritty an fast paced, it’s awfully hard to capture that in a comic…
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a reply
Be Heard @ ComicNerd
ComicNerds Online
Creator Directory
Categories
Meta
Don't Miss A Thing:
Top Posters
Find a comic shop near you
Get this widget at ComicNerd.comMost Popular Posts
Recent Posts
Calendar
Blogroll