25 Jul
Posted by omg_brb_icecreamtruck as Mark Miller, Marvel 1985, Marvel Comics, Tommy Lee Edwards

Storyline: The Visitors
Date: July 16th, 2008
Price: $3.99 US
Writer: Mark Millar
Artist: Tommy Lee Edwards
Synopsis: They’re coming for us. The most dangerous villains in the Marvel Universe are here—in our world—and they’re not taking prisoners. The only people who stand between salvation and destruction are 13-year old Toby and his dad, who once was friends with the enigmatic Clyde Wyncham.
Opinion: We have reached the middle of the new series, 1985 and so far it’s been a let down. Don’t get me wrong the concept is really cool; for those of you who are new to this series the whole idea is that all the comic book characters, good and bad, have descended into this small town to… well we’re not really sure why they’re there yet. Anyway it’s narrated by the older version of the 12 year-old boy who lived though the whole experience. The idea behind the story line is great except the series has yet to amaze.
Read my full review after the jump.
So far most of it has been narration and this issue is no different. The “older/wiser” version of our 12 year-old continues to drone on about the happenings instead of showing us. Another problem I had with issue #2 has been resolved with very minimal impact to the town or to our narrator. A man was electrocuted at the end of the second issue, but in this story he is mentioned very briefly and has been found dead, not really very climatic.
If the concept of the story is the invasion of the comic book characters shouldn’t more things be happening then people dying ?!?! This whole issue focused on the death and destruction of the town. Just fantastic except let’s have more of a plot twist, death is pretty final, what about some of the people living to help the good or the bad?
The other issue I keep having with this comic is my own doing. I am new to the comic book world and therefore the characters they keep mentioning mean nothing to me. This is particularly hard when they don’t explain their powers or abilities. For instance part of the story has the bad guy Capitan America always goes up against controlling hundreds of people with his mind and forcing them to do things they don’t want to do. I have no idea who this nemesis of Capitan America is, I have no back story, no knowledge of what he’s done or not done so I can’t get excited about him or about any of the other comic book characters that have made appearances so far. At the end of the issue is a big green dragon??? No clue.
It’s really hard to get into a story when I don’t understand the characters involved. On a semi related note I’ve run into this problem before, it seems like the comic book industry is a big club and you have to know the history of all the characters to really enjoy the new stuff coming out. This is absolute BS, if the industry wants to enjoy new clientèle it needs to be easier to get involved in new story lines. Just my 2 cents.
// Remember! You do not have to register in order to post comments!
Rate This Issue:
3 Responses
JC
July 24th, 2008 at 10:44 pm
1I seriously disagree with you - this comic has been excellent! I am loving this story and I feel Millar has been capturing the enchanting feeling you get as a young comic book reader in his main character.
Furthermore, Edwards has been doing an excellent job giving the whole book a Bronze age feel. The features are a bit murky sometimes, though.
HOWEVER.
I do see what you mean. This is a comic book for dare I say it: comic book veterans. There is no way with your lack of comic book history you would recognize or care about who Fing Fang Foom is or who M.O.D.O.K. is (though to be fair, if I remember correctly, both are named in the dialogue).
This raises an interesting point, though. This comic is to an extent an inside joke for comic book fans that have been around a while. This doesn’t seem fair to new readers and I believe care should be taken to explain to readers who is who. It’s a common plague, though.
Stephanie
July 29th, 2008 at 7:22 pm
2An overall good comic is one that is balanced: not only in art and storyline, but in narration. It has to be easy to follow and ease new readers into the story and get them interested while simultaneously giving old readers new gems and excitement. It’s hard sometimes, but certainly by no means impossible. Yeah, you’re not going to know EVERYthing if you’re a new reader—but you shouldn’t have to to enjoy a comic.
If the only people who can enjoy a title is someone who is extremely familiar with it—then in my opinion, it just isn’t an overall great comic. Great comics cater to old and new audiences.
But if you’re an old reader and you thought it was great—then hey, it was great. Maybe it is: but it STILL should do a better job to welcome new readers. It shouldn’t be pretentious: like, ahem, Grant Morrison’s current Batman storyline. Seriously, I’m a big Bat-fan and these obscure references are just ridiculous. But that’s a whole different story.
New Comics for 07/30/08 + Tuesday Wrap-Up by ComicNerd: Comic Book Reviews
July 30th, 2008 at 7:01 am
3[...] ComicNerd Review: Marvel 1985 #3 [...]
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a reply
Be Heard @ ComicNerd
ComicNerds Online
Creator Directory
Categories
Meta
Don't Miss A Thing:
Top Posters
Find a comic shop near you
Get this widget at ComicNerd.comMost Popular Posts
Recent Posts
Calendar
Blogroll