21 May
Posted by ComicNerd as Frank D'Armata, Marvel Comics, Mike Carey, Scot Eaton, X-Men

Storyline: Sins of the Father part 1 (of 3)
Date: May 14, 2008
Price: $2.99 US
Writer: Mike Carey
Artists: Scot Eaton and Frank D’Armata
Synopsis: Professor X is trying to rebuild memories of his past using other people’s minds. But the past is coming back to haunt him in another way, as a swathe of tragic deaths turns out to be linked by only one factor: Brian Xavier, the Professor’s long-dead father. And solving the mystery means paying a visit to the Hellfire Club…
Opinion: I’m a bit biased on this issue, I’ll warn you now! Why is that, you might ask; it’s because of the return of my favorite character! I won’t tell you who it is until after the jump - but it was one of those moments where I flipped to the last page and actually got excited (which rarely happens when I read a comic anymore). That in and of itself made this issue a highlight for me.
With this in mind, I’ll still try to make a fair review, check it out after the jump!
After the events in Messiah CompleX, we didn’t know what was going to happen to our favorite bald visionary, Professor X. ‘Ole Chuck has been through some stuff, let me tell you that - but losing his memories a la Wolverine style is a bit of a redundancy. I guess the story has to move along somehow.
I’m not too sure about the involvement of Cassandra Nova, the twin sister of Xavier who.. ok, let me just quote Wikipedia on this:
Cassandra Nova began life at the same time as Charles Xavier. Conceived without a body, Cassandra improvised one by copying Xavier’s DNA to make her own body, effectively becoming his twin sister. She grew with her brother until the time when Charles sensed her monstrous thoughts. Charles attempted to kill the creature, resulting in its physical body being stillborn. Despite this, the creature survived as chaotic cellular matter and clung to a sewer wall for decades, rebuilding its physical form and perfecting its effort to mimic human traits. During this time, she grew convinced that the womb in which she had fought Charles and the universe she now inhabited were one and the same, a universe in which only she and Charles were real, and that her purpose was to destroy every illusion Charles held dear: his dream, his X-Men and his beloved Lilandra.
Jean Grey later discovered that Cassandra Nova is the mummudrai (from a Shi’ar legend, meaning opposite) of Charles Xavier. “Legend says each of us faces our own personal mummudrai in the womb, shortly before birth - it is our first experience of the alien, the other, the different”. In reality, the mummudrai are a parasitic species born bodiless on the astral plane, and it was only through becoming entangled with Charles Xavier’s developing telepathic mind that Cassandra Nova created a body for herself.
Now, let me point out that Cassandra Nova was a creation of Grant Morrison, who the more I learn about the less I dig his story lines. Either way, it is a plot device to move Charles to grow as a character, which is always a good thing.
Throughout this issue, we see Charles is being hunted by some soldiers wearing some sort of protection against psychic detection. He is at their mercy with no awareness of their ambush or a way to defend himself with his powers, when none other than Gambit (highlight to be spoiled) shows up to confront the soldiers about to descend upon Xavier! Whoohoo!
Overall, this book is pure X-Men fun, as always. We get some important backstory, some details revealed about Mr. Sinister’s role in Xavier’s development and some rich character insight based on Xavier’s travels.
This was a good issue, and I think the pacing is appropriate for the sotry and the money.
// Remember! You do not have to register in order to post comments!
Rate This Issue:
4 Responses
Stephanie
May 21st, 2008 at 1:57 pm
1Ahh, good ol’ wikipedia.
Love the X-men (and the spoiler character, definitely one of my faves)! I’ll have to track this down.
JC
May 22nd, 2008 at 9:15 am
2Yeah, I gave up on it for a while - but the Astonishing run and the return of this character since issue #200 has brought me back in. The current changes going on are pretty exciting to say the least.
I would definitely recommend picking up messiah CompleX when it comes out in trade; that story smacked quite a bit of good ‘ole X-Men I remember.
Stephanie
May 29th, 2008 at 10:37 am
3Read this issue and it was really cool!
New Comics for 06/04/08 + Tuesday Wrap-Up by ComicNerd: Comic Book Reviews
June 3rd, 2008 at 2:42 pm
4[...] X-Men #211 [...]
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a reply
Be Heard @ ComicNerd
Creator Directory
Categories
Meta
Don't Miss A Thing:
Find a comic shop near you
Get this widget at ComicNerd.comMost Popular Posts
Recent Posts
Calendar
Blogroll
Tags
Batman Batman RIP Brian Michael Bendis catwoman dark knight DC DC Universe detective Detective Comics Dustin Nguyen Freddie Williams II G.I. Joe Gambit Grant Morrison Hulk Icon Comics Image Comics Iron Man J.T. Krul John Romita Jr. joss_whedon Kick-Ass Mark Millar Marvel Marvel Comics Marvel Universe Movies Paul Dini Professor X Robert Kirkman Robin Sandu Florea Secret Invasion Skaar Sky Doll Superman Terminator Thor Tony Daniel Transformers Watchmen Webcomics Wolverine X-Force X-MenBe Heard @ ComicNerd!
DISCLAIMER: All images, names, likenesses and references to characters, titles and publishers are protected under trademark and copyright laws by their respective owners. ComicNerd features a user-generated comment system, wherein users can submit their opinions relating to what we report. ComicNerd assumes no liability or responsibility to the comments assigned to particular topics, and does it's best to remove all inappropriate or irrelevant content. ComicNerd: Comic Book Reviews is proudly powered by WordPress with a big thank you to - Design Disease