16 Jul
Posted by omg_brb_icecreamtruck as Mark Miller, Marvel 1985, Marvel Comics, Ramblings

Storyline: Clyde Wyncham
Date: June 25th, 2008
Price: $3.99
Writer: Mark Millar
Artist: Tommy Lee Edwards
Synopsis: Marvel’s most deadly villains have a foothold in the real world—but who will believe the only person who knows the truth, when that person is a 13-year old kid named Toby who’s read way too many comic books? Fortunately, it seems that Toby has an ally—the Incredible Hulk! Can even the Hulk survive the most titanic throw-down with Juggernaut in comic book history? Find out in this epic clash of super hero action…and ponder—who is Clyde Wyncham?
Opinion: The second edition of 1985 was a little more disappointing than the first. Don’t get me wrong the art was the same style of old comic book and the story line was still very interesting but the issue seemed a little like a filler between major action issues (at least that’s my hope).
Read the full review after the jump.
My biggest problem is the narration, it tells the story but it doesn’t leave any room for action, if I wanted a story I would buy a book, what I want is pictures I want to be shown the story not told it. Not only is the narration taking away from the story it is being written in the third person by an older Toby who is musing on his own childhood. I’d much rather see it from the perspective of a 13 year-old boy whose just found out that the whole town has become a gathering place of all Marvel characters. I think young Toby might be a whole lot more excited than the old Toby who keeps alluding to more to come.
Another issue I have is the ending. The ending switches to a couple on the other side of town who currently have no relation with Toby and their unusual problem with a Marvel character. Uhhhh?? WTF??? How the heck did this even make it into the issue? Isn’t there an easier way to introduce a new character, maybe through narration since that seems like a popular angle? I spent the last 3 pages saying; uh? It’s very hard to follow and even harder to read.
One more and then I’ll stop…Toby narrates that his dad is smart and useless until something happens, but keeps that something a “secret” until next story. Really!? Is that really necessary, let’s keep the suspense with the Marvel comic book characters coming to life and not some dead beat dad who might just turn out to be a good thing in his kid’s life.
I just hope the next issue will have a little more action AND story, not just the latter. It’ll be interesting to see if this series gets better.
// Remember! You do not have to register in order to post comments!
Rate This Issue:
4 Responses
JC
July 16th, 2008 at 8:16 am
1I don’t know, I personally am enjoying the hell out of this story. Mark Millar seems to be hitting the target on this one.
I loved the part talking about Hulk’s smell, was a really funny angle on some 13 year old being face to face with the Hulk.
michael
July 16th, 2008 at 11:21 am
2Hmm. I read the synopsis for this book a couple months ago and couldn’t find the appeal. Especially after being burned by “Powerless” a couple years ago. Sounds like it may have some value though as I like my comics with more story than pictures. Maybe i’ll wait for the trade. Thanks for the review!
redhollywood
July 16th, 2008 at 6:07 pm
3I didn’t pick this story up solely because I can’t spend anymore money on comcis. I will read the tpb when it comes out.
New Comics for 07/23/08 + Tuesday Wrap-Up by ComicNerd: Comic Book Reviews
July 22nd, 2008 at 3:05 pm
4[...] ComicNerd Review: Marvel 1985 #2 [...]
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a reply
Be Heard @ ComicNerd
ComicNerds Online
Creator Directory
Categories
Meta
Don't Miss A Thing:
Top Posters
Find a comic shop near you
Get this widget at ComicNerd.comMost Popular Posts
Recent Posts
Calendar
Blogroll
Be Heard @ ComicNerd!
DISCLAIMER: All images, names, likenesses and references to characters, titles and publishers are protected under trademark and copyright laws by their respective owners. ComicNerd features a user-generated comment system, wherein users can submit their opinions relating to what we report. ComicNerd assumes no liability or responsibility to the comments assigned to particular topics, and does it's best to remove all inappropriate or irrelevant content. ComicNerd: Comic Book Reviews is proudly powered by WordPress with a big thank you to - Design Disease